Some time ago, I wrote about the inevitable souring of TNE dreams in India. In today’s essay, I dig deeper.
Want to listen to the essay in a podcast format? Click the image below:
Category Archives: #Essays
The Fifth Wall: On Form, Formlessness, and the Divine
I. The Boundary That Names Itself
Imagine trying to explain the sun and the moon and the stars to a kindergartener. The moon is a ball of cheese, the stars are angels, and the sun is a giant light bulb. All parties are satisfied.
This is the closest I have come to explaining the tetragrammaton, that ancient, unpronounceable name that sits at the heart of the Hebrew Bible like a locked door. There is no vocabulary, no repertoire in the child that could help her comprehend the idea that the moon is a piece of rock reflecting the sun’s light, that the stars are burning balls of gas light-years away, that nuclear fusion powers the sun’s heart. She will understand these things one day, but not yet. Not with the words she has now.
“I am that I am.”
What one encounters in this strange non-answer is not evasion but precision. It refuses metaphor. It refuses descriptive content. It refuses the kind of conceptual scaffolding we normally use to explain reality. Instead, it names something that cannot be situated within cause-and-effect, or comparison, or analogy.
The kindergarten version of God is always some combination of an old man in the sky, a benevolent force, a moral judge, a cosmic engineer. None of these are inherently wrong – they are simply the conceptual toys we play with until our minds grow enough to ask: What, then, stands behind even these?
At that point, “I am that I am” is not an answer. It is a boundary.
One can almost hear the text saying: “You do not have the categories required to understand the thing you’re asking about. So take this – not as a definition, but as a placeholder for a reality that exceeds your present vocabulary.”
A bit like telling a child that the sun is a light bulb until her mind is ready to encounter thermonuclear fusion. Not because the light-bulb story is true, but because it is merciful.
The tetragrammaton is mercy of the same order. It does not describe God. It protects us from thinking that our descriptions are God.
And somewhere in that refusal – that radical non-definition – lies the deepest affirmation: that the ground of being is not grasped by names but encountered in experience. In stillness. In those interior flashes where one’s own existence feels both impossibly fragile and inexplicably held.
In those moments, “I am that I am” ceases to sound like a riddle. It becomes recognition. A whisper that says: The reality behind all realities cannot be cradled in words – not even sacred ones.
Modern Rituals – Addendum
In a world addicted to noise, silence has become the last act of faith.
There was a time when silence meant presence. Now it feels like absence. We fill every crevice of consciousness with commentary, fearing what the quiet might reveal. Yet beneath the noise, small rituals still survive – gestures that whisper rather than shout, full of love, hope, and protection.
This essay continues the “Modern Rituals” series – reflections on how the sacred survives in the gestures of everyday life.
The Rituals of Noise
We have mistaken volume for vitality.
Every day begins with a buzz, ends with a scroll, and in between, we drown in the sound of our own broadcasting. We talk about “connection”, but what we crave is confirmation – that we still exist, that we still matter, that the world hasn’t forgotten our name in the feed.
Noise has become our modern incense.
We burn it constantly, afraid of what might appear in the silence that follows. Our need to comment, reply, and react has become a liturgy without faith – movement without meaning.
In The Guardian, Shadi Khan Saif writes: “People survive not just through faith but through the small things they do when no one’s watching; the quiet rituals and little beliefs that live in everyday life.” It’s a gentle reminder that not all worship happens in temples or timelines. The true gestures of the soul are small, unpublicised, and wordless.
Our modern rituals, by contrast, are noisy because they are insecure. The louder we shout, the less we seem to believe in what we’re saying. We’ve built an economy of attention where silence is treated as a fault in the system. Algorithms panic when you pause. Apps prod you back to speech. Even grief now comes with a “share” button.
The tragedy isn’t that we’ve lost the divine.
It’s that we’ve lost the quiet in which the divine could once be heard.
The Return to the Whisper
And yet – not all is lost.
Saif’s piece reminds us: “They’re not loud, not official. But they’re full of love and hope.” Somewhere beneath the static, small acts of reverence still survive – lighting a diya at dusk, a hand over the heart before a flight, a whispered “thank you” to no one in particular. These are our unnoticed prayers, carried out in the hush between larger noises.
In the old texts, silence was a sign of listening; in our time, it has become an act of rebellion. To sit still for ten minutes without touching a device is now radical. To walk without earbuds is a pilgrimage. To look at the sky without photographing it is prayer.
“These seemingly small gestures,” Saif observes, “hold more than superstition. They carry virtues: grounding, comfort and a deep sense of protection.” That, perhaps, is what the whisper really is – a reminder that truth doesn’t compete for your attention. It waits.
Maybe silence was never meant to be an escape, but a return – the slow homecoming of awareness to itself. The whisper, whether it comes from a prophet, a verse, or the soft interior of your own breath, is the same voice that has always spoken beneath the noise. We just need to stop long enough to hear it.
Epilogue: The Sound of Returning
Silence was once a homeland.
Every word began from it, every prayer returned to it. We have wandered far, building temples of noise, mistaking echoes for answers. But perhaps the sacred was never lost – only muffled beneath our constant need to speak.
In the beginning, there was no command, no thunder, no proclamation. There was only breath – the same breath that stirs the reed, the same that carries a whisper across a room. Maybe God still speaks that way. Maybe the divine frequency has not changed – only our bandwidth has.
When the noise fades, what remains is not emptiness, but presence.
It is in that quiet that the world becomes audible again – the heartbeat of things, the rustle of what endures.
So, close the tab.
Let the room go still.
And listen – not for what’s next, but for what has always been speaking softly beneath it all.
“People survive not just through faith but through the small things they do when no one’s watching; the quiet rituals and little beliefs that live in everyday life. They’re not loud, not official. But they’re full of love and hope. These seemingly small gestures … hold more than superstition. They carry virtues: grounding, comfort and a deep sense of protection.”
– Shadi Khan Saif, “Spirituality isn’t rigid dogma. It’s a living, breathing practice that helps make sense of an incomprehensible world,”
The Guardian, 20 October 2025. Read full article →